Today in school, we practiced our debate of whether we should learn French before another language or if we should have the choice of any language in elementary. We had some issues with time, as it was very long. We can improve our working speed so the debate will take up less time. We are going to have the final or polished debate tomorrow, in front of parents and the grade 5 and 6’s of Garneau School.Here are some of the arguments for each side of the debate:
For French First:
-Can use it all over Canada and other places in the world.
-Educational reasons: If you want to go into a French emersion class in junior high and high school, you will have that option and be prepared for it.
-French is part of Canadian history and heritage.
-There are a lot of jobs that you can get if you speak both French and English.
-You can communicate with French Canadians and other Francophones if they are visiting and don’t speak a lot of English.
For the Choice of any Language:
-You should be able to have a choice. Garneau places great value on freedom of choice and student input in decisions, so if this is an important value at Garneau School we should have choices that are consistent with that.
-People should be able to learn their native language (if it’s not French or English) in school before being required to learn French which would be their third language.
-There are many languages that are more commonly spoken than French. Cantonese and Mandarin are important for doing business with countries such as China.
-There are more and more people who speak other languages that are immigrating into Canada. French is becoming less and less common.
By N & D

